Error with ggplot2 mapping variable to y and using stat=“bin”

Question

I am using ggplot2 to make a histogram:

geom_histogram(aes(x=...), y=\"..ncount../sum(..ncount..)\")

and I get the error:

M         


        

Answer 1

The confusion here is a long standing one (as evidenced by the verbose warning message) that all starts with stat_bin.

But users don't typically realize that their confusion revolves around stat_bin, since they typically encounter problems while using either geom_bar or geom_histogram. Note the documentation for each: they both use stat = "bin" (in current ggplot2 versions this stat has been split into stat_bin for continuous data and stat_count for discrete data) by default.

But let's back up. geom_*'s control the actual rendering of data into some sort of geometric form. stat_*'s simply transform your data. The distinction is a bit confusing in practice, because adding a layer of stat_bin will, by default, invoke geom_bar and so it can seem indistinguishable from geom_bar when you're learning.

In any case, consider the "bar"-like geom's: histograms and bar charts. Both are clearly going to involve some binning of data somewhere along the line. But our data could either be pre-summarised or not. For instance, we might want a bar plot from:

x
a
a
a
b
b
b

or equivalently from

x  y
a  3
b  3

The first hasn't been binned yet. The second is pre-binned. The default behavior for both geom_bar and geom_histogram is to assume that you have not pre-binned your data. So they will attempt to call stat_bin (for histograms, now stat_count for bar charts) on your x values.

As the warning says, it will then try to map y for you to the resulting counts. If you also attempt to map y yourself to some other variable you end up in Here There Be Dragons territory. Mapping y to functions of the variables returned by stat_bin (..count.., etc.) should be ok and should not throw that warning (it doesn't for me using @mnel's example above).

The take-away here is that for geom_bar if you've pre-computed the heights of the bars, always remember to use stat = "identity", or better yet use the newer geom_col which uses stat = "identity" by default. For geom_histogram it's very unlikely that you will have pre-computed the bins, so in most cases you just need to remember not to map y to anything beyond what's returned from stat_bin.

geom_dotplot uses it's own binning stat, stat_bindot, and this discussion applies here as well, I believe. This sort of thing generally hasn't been an issue with the 2d binning cases (geom_bin2d and geom_hex) since there hasn't been as much flexibility available in the analogous z variable to the binned y variable in the 1d case. If future updates start allowing more fancy manipulations of the 2d binning cases this could I suppose become something you have to watch out for there.