HTTPS vs HTTP speed comparison

Question

Update 2013-04-25:

This is a popular question that is getting more attention than it probably should. In order to stop the spread of misinformation please read

Answer 1

Are you accessing your site through a proxy? If so, you may be seeing better performance because the proxy is being bypassed or reduced to just using handling the initial CONNECT requests.

A proxy could be checking and caching content when you use HTTP - leading to reduced performance.