Attempting to get completely free SSL on Heroku using Cloudflares new free Universal SSL
Read this article: http://mikecoutermarsh.com/adding-ssl-to-heroku-with-clou
This does work exactly as I had it set up. The problem was that it took a couple days for CloudFlare to issue their Unlimited SSL. Once it says 'SSL active' under your CloudFlare SSL settings, it will work.