Can different git-svn clones of the same svn repository expect to be able to share changes then git svn dcommit?

Question

I\'ve read a great deal of \"go from svn to git\" and other \"git-svn workflow\" articles on the web, and still I think they often deal with overly simple situations. They a

Answer 1

One of the problems I perceive with git-svn is that it stores the git-svn-id in the commit comment ; because this rewrites that commit, it changes it's SHA1, so you can't push it anywhere people will be sharing it.

I actually prefer bzr-svn because instead it stores the bzr revid in the remote SVN revision using the SVN revision properties feature instead which means no local revision rewrite. It also has the property desired, that two independent pulls of the same SVN branch will result in identical and interoperable bzr branches.