How to implement breadcrumbs in a Django template?

Question

Some solutions provided on doing a Google search for \"Django breadcrumbs\" include using templates and block.super, basically just extending the base blocks and adding the

Answer 1

http://www.djangosnippets.org/snippets/1289/ - provides a template tag but i'm not sure this would work if you don't have your urls.py properly declared.

Nothing will work if you don't have your urls.py properly declared. Having said that, it doesn't look as though it imports from urls.py. In fact, it looks like to properly use that tag, you still have to pass the template some variables. Okay, that's not quite true: indirectly through the default url tag, which the breadcrumb tag calls. But as far as I can figure, it doesn't even actually call that tag; all occurrences of url are locally created variables.

But I'm no expert at parsing template tag definitions. So say somewhere else in the code it magically replicates the functionality of the url tag. The usage seems to be that you pass in arguments to a reverse lookup. Again, no matter what your project is, you urls.py should be configured so that any view can be reached with a reverse lookup. This is especially true with breadcrumbs. Think about it:

home > accounts > my account

Should accounts, ever hold an arbitrary, hardcoded url? Could "my account" ever hold an arbitrary, hardcoded url? Some way, somehow you're going to write breadcrumbs in such a way that your urls.py gets reversed. That's really only going to happen in one of two places: in your view, with a call to reverse, or in the template, with a call to a template tag that mimics the functionality of reverse. There may be reasons to prefer the former over the latter (into which the linked snippet locks you), but avoiding a logical configuration of your urls.py file is not one of them.