REST HTTP status codes for failed validation or invalid duplicate

Question

I am building an application with a REST-based API and have come to the point where I am specifying status codes for each requests.

What status code should i send for

Answer 1

• Failed validation: 403 Forbidden ("The server understood the request, but is refusing to fulfill it"). Contrary to popular opinion, RFC2616 doesn't say "403 is only intended for failed authentication", but "403: I know what you want, but I won't do that". That condition may or may not be due to authentication.
• Trying to add a duplicate: 409 Conflict ("The request could not be completed due to a conflict with the current state of the resource.")

You should definitely give a more detailed explanation in the response headers and/or body (e.g. with a custom header - X-Status-Reason: Validation failed).