Creating a composite foreign key in SQL Server 2008

Question

I have two tables that I\'d like to create a foreign key for.

Primary Table

PK - Key1 - varchar(20)
PK - Key2 - date

Answer 1

Some of this is focused, some of this is context for others having any sort of problem like this (like anyone actually searches first?)

The first thing to check when you have a problem creating a key is make sure you did not mismatch the data types in the two tables. If you have an bigint in one and an int in the other, it will blow. This is true on all keys, but more likely to crop up if you use multiple fields. Simple math shows the reason why the chance increases.

The next issue is data. If you cannot create the key due to data, you have to find out what exists in the child table that does not exist in the parent table. LEFT JOIN the tables (secondary on the second/left side of the join) and only include rows where the primary table is null. You will either have to create these records in the parent table or get rid of them.

One way "around" this is set up a new primary key on the parent table. You then create a foreign key on this new primary key and match as many records as you can in the child table. You then have the join set up and you can go about cleaning as a secondary operation.

Which is better? New primary key or working with the composite key? This really depends on the nature of the data, but I am more fond of using a derived key over a natural key or a composite key. But, there are times where the work necessary to get a single field derived key is a lot of work.