I am trying to remove a certain color from my image however it\'s not working as well as I\'d hoped. I tried to do the same thing as seen here Using PIL to make all white pi
The best way to do it is to use the "color to alpha" algorithm used in Gimp to replace a color. It will work perfectly in your case. I reimplemented this algorithm using PIL for an open source python photo processor phatch. You can find the full implementation here. This a pure PIL implementation and it doesn't have other dependences. You can copy the function code and use it. Here is a sample using Gimp:
to 
You can apply the color_to_alpha function on the image using black as the color. Then paste the image on a different background color to do the replacement.
By the way, this implementation uses the ImageMath module in PIL. It is much more efficient than accessing pixels using getdata.
EDIT: Here is the full code:
from PIL import Image, ImageMath
def difference1(source, color):
"""When source is bigger than color"""
return (source - color) / (255.0 - color)
def difference2(source, color):
"""When color is bigger than source"""
return (color - source) / color
def color_to_alpha(image, color=None):
image = image.convert('RGBA')
width, height = image.size
color = map(float, color)
img_bands = [band.convert("F") for band in image.split()]
# Find the maximum difference rate between source and color. I had to use two
# difference functions because ImageMath.eval only evaluates the expression
# once.
alpha = ImageMath.eval(
"""float(
max(
max(
max(
difference1(red_band, cred_band),
difference1(green_band, cgreen_band)
),
difference1(blue_band, cblue_band)
),
max(
max(
difference2(red_band, cred_band),
difference2(green_band, cgreen_band)
),
difference2(blue_band, cblue_band)
)
)
)""",
difference1=difference1,
difference2=difference2,
red_band = img_bands[0],
green_band = img_bands[1],
blue_band = img_bands[2],
cred_band = color[0],
cgreen_band = color[1],
cblue_band = color[2]
)
# Calculate the new image colors after the removal of the selected color
new_bands = [
ImageMath.eval(
"convert((image - color) / alpha + color, 'L')",
image = img_bands[i],
color = color[i],
alpha = alpha
)
for i in xrange(3)
]
# Add the new alpha band
new_bands.append(ImageMath.eval(
"convert(alpha_band * alpha, 'L')",
alpha = alpha,
alpha_band = img_bands[3]
))
return Image.merge('RGBA', new_bands)
image = color_to_alpha(image, (0, 0, 0, 255))
background = Image.new('RGB', image.size, (255, 255, 255))
background.paste(image.convert('RGB'), mask=image)