IDs must be unique--you can't have more than one element with the same ID in an html document. Classes can be used for multiple elements. In this case, you would want to use an ID for "main" because it's (presumably) unique--it's the "main" div that serves as a container for your other content and there will only be one.
If you have a bunch of menu buttons or some other element for which you want the styling repeated, you would assign them all to the same class and then style that class.
