Using Moq to verify calls are made in the correct order

Question

I need to test the following method:

CreateOutput(IWriter writer)
{
    writer.Write(type);
    writer.Write(id);
    writer.Write(sender);

    // many more         


        

Answer 1

I wrote an extension method that will assert based on order of invocation.

public static class MockExtensions
{
  public static void ExpectsInOrder(this Mock mock, params Expression>[] expressions) where T : class
  {
    // All closures have the same instance of sharedCallCount
    var sharedCallCount = 0;
    for (var i = 0; i < expressions.Length; i++)
    {
      // Each closure has it's own instance of expectedCallCount
      var expectedCallCount = i;
      mock.Setup(expressions[i]).Callback(
        () =>
          {
            Assert.AreEqual(expectedCallCount, sharedCallCount);
            sharedCallCount++;
          });
    }
  }
}

It works by taking advantage of the way that closures work with respect to scoped variables. Since there is only one declaration for sharedCallCount, all of the closures will have a reference to the same variable. With expectedCallCount, a new instance is instantiated each iteration of the loop (as opposed to simply using i in the closure). This way, each closure has a copy of i scoped only to itself to compare with the sharedCallCount when the expressions are invoked.

Here's a small unit test for the extension. Note that this method is called in your setup section, not your assertion section.

[TestFixture]
public class MockExtensionsTest
{
  [TestCase]
  {
    // Setup
    var mock = new Mock();
    mock.ExpectsInOrder(
      x => x.MyMethod("1"),
      x => x.MyMethod("2"));

    // Fake the object being called in order
    mock.Object.MyMethod("1");
    mock.Object.MyMethod("2");
  }

  [TestCase]
  {
    // Setup
    var mock = new Mock();
    mock.ExpectsInOrder(
      x => x.MyMethod("1"),
      x => x.MyMethod("2"));

    // Fake the object being called out of order
    Assert.Throws(() => mock.Object.MyMethod("2"));
  }
}

public interface IAmAnInterface
{
  void MyMethod(string param);
}