Currently I\'m doing some unit tests which are executed from bash. Unit tests are initialized, executed and cleaned up in a bash script. This script usualy contains an init(
Testing different solutions:
#!/bin/bash
test_declare () {
declare -f f > /dev/null
}
test_declare2 () {
declare -F f > /dev/null
}
test_type () {
type -t f | grep -q 'function'
}
test_type2 () {
[[ $(type -t f) = function ]]
}
funcs=(test_declare test_declare2 test_type test_type2)
test () {
for i in $(seq 1 1000); do $1; done
}
f () {
echo 'This is a test function.'
echo 'This has more than one command.'
return 0
}
post='(f is function)'
for j in 1 2 3; do
for func in ${funcs[@]}; do
echo $func $post
time test $func
echo exit code $?; echo
done
case $j in
1) unset -f f
post='(f unset)'
;;
2) f='string'
post='(f is string)'
;;
esac
done
outputs e.g.:
test_declare (f is function)
real 0m0,055s user 0m0,041s sys 0m0,004s exit code 0
test_declare2 (f is function)
real 0m0,042s user 0m0,022s sys 0m0,017s exit code 0
test_type (f is function)
real 0m2,200s user 0m1,619s sys 0m1,008s exit code 0
test_type2 (f is function)
real 0m0,746s user 0m0,534s sys 0m0,237s exit code 0
test_declare (f unset)
real 0m0,040s user 0m0,029s sys 0m0,010s exit code 1
test_declare2 (f unset)
real 0m0,038s user 0m0,038s sys 0m0,000s exit code 1
test_type (f unset)
real 0m2,438s user 0m1,678s sys 0m1,045s exit code 1
test_type2 (f unset)
real 0m0,805s user 0m0,541s sys 0m0,274s exit code 1
test_declare (f is string)
real 0m0,043s user 0m0,034s sys 0m0,007s exit code 1
test_declare2 (f is string)
real 0m0,039s user 0m0,035s sys 0m0,003s exit code 1
test_type (f is string)
real 0m2,394s user 0m1,679s sys 0m1,035s exit code 1
test_type2 (f is string)
real 0m0,851s user 0m0,554s sys 0m0,294s exit code 1
So declare -F f seems to be the best solution.