Advantages of std::for_each over for loop

Question

Are there any advantages of std::for_each over for loop? To me, std::for_each only seems to hinder the readability of code. Why do then some coding

Answer 1

I find for_each to be bad for readability. The concept is a good one but c++ makes it very hard to write readable, at least for me. c++0x lamda expressions will help. I really like the idea of lamdas. However on first glance I think the syntax is very ugly and I'm not 100% sure I'll ever get used to it. Maybe in 5 years I'll have got used to it and not give it a second thought, but maybe not. Time will tell :)

I prefer to use

vector::iterator istart = container.begin();
vector::iterator iend = container.end();
for(vector::iterator i = istart; i != iend; ++i) {
  // Do stuff
}

I find an explicit for loop clearer to read and explicity using named variables for the start and end iterators reduces the clutter in the for loop.

Of course cases vary, this is just what I usually find best.