Disclaimer: I have figured out the problem (I think), but I wanted to add this issue to Stack Overflow since I couldn\'t (easily) find it anywhere. Also, someone might
this worked for me :)
select * from Common where common_id not in (select ISNULL(common_id,'dummy-data') from Table1) and common_id not in (select ISNULL(common_id,'dummy-data') from Table2)
select * from Common
where
common_id not in (select ISNULL(common_id,'dummy-data') from Table1)
and common_id not in (select ISNULL(common_id,'dummy-data') from Table2)