Can a pointer (address) ever be negative?

Question

I have a function that I would like to be able to return special values for failure and uninitialized (it returns a pointer on success).

Currently i

Answer 1

The C language does not define the notion of "negativity" for pointers. The property of "being negative" is a chiefly arithmetical one, not in any way applicable to values of pointer type.

If you have a pointer-returning function, then you cannot meaningfully return the value of -1 from that function. In C language integral values (other than zero) are not implicitly convertible to pointer types. An attempt to return -1 from a pointer-returning function is an immediate constraint violation that will result in diagnostic message. In short, it is an error. If your compiler allows it, it simply means that it doesn't enforce that constraint too strictly (most of the time they do it for compatibility with pre-standard code).

If you force the value of -1 to pointer type by an explicit cast, the result of the cast will be implementation-defined. The language itself makes no guarantees about it. It might easily prove to be the same as some other, valid pointer value.

If you want to create a reserved pointer value, there no need to malloc anything. You can simple declare a global variable of the desired type and use its address as the reserved value. It is guaranteed to be unique.