How do I generate a random int number?

Question

How do I generate a random integer in C#?

Answer 1

The question looks very simple but the answer is bit complicated. If you see almost everyone has suggested to use the Random class and some have suggested to use the RNG crypto class. But then when to choose what.

For that we need to first understand the term RANDOMNESS and the philosophy behind it.

I would encourage you to watch this video which goes in depth in the philosophy of RANDOMNESS using C# https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCYxc-2-3fY

First thing let us understand the philosophy of RANDOMNESS. When we tell a person to choose between RED, GREEN and YELLOW what happens internally. What makes a person choose RED or YELLOW or GREEN?

Some initial thought goes into the persons mind which decides his choice, it can be favorite color , lucky color and so on. In other words some initial trigger which we term in RANDOM as SEED.This SEED is the beginning point, the trigger which instigates him to select the RANDOM value.

Now if a SEED is easy to guess then those kind of random numbers are termed as PSEUDO and when a seed is difficult to guess those random numbers are termed SECURED random numbers.

For example a person chooses is color depending on weather and sound combination then it would be difficult to guess the initial seed.

Now let me make an important statement:-

*“Random” class generates only PSEUDO random number and to generate SECURE random number we need to use “RNGCryptoServiceProvider” class.

Random class takes seed values from your CPU clock which is very much predictable. So in other words RANDOM class of C# generates pseudo random numbers , below is the code for the same.

var random = new Random();
int randomnumber = random.Next()

While the RNGCryptoServiceProvider class uses OS entropy to generate seeds. OS entropy is a random value which is generated using sound, mouse click, and keyboard timings, thermal temp etc. Below goes the code for the same.

using (RNGCryptoServiceProvider rg = new RNGCryptoServiceProvider()) 
{ 
    byte[] rno = new byte[5];    
    rg.GetBytes(rno);    
    int randomvalue = BitConverter.ToInt32(rno, 0); 
}

To understand OS entropy see this video from 14:30 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCYxc-2-3fY where the logic of OS entropy is explained. So putting in simple words RNG Crypto generates SECURE random numbers.