Business Logic: Database or Application Layer

Question

The age old question. Where should you put your business logic, in the database as stored procedures ( or packages ), or in the application/middle tier? And more importantly

Answer 1

This is a great question! I found this after I had already asked a simliar question, but this is more specific. It came up as a result of a design change decision that I wasn't involved in making.

Basically, what I was told was that If you have millions of rows of data in your database tables, then look at putting business logic into stored procedures and triggers. That is what we are doing right now, converting a java app into stored procedures for maintainability as the java code had become convoluted.

I found this article on: The Business Logic Wars The author also made the million rows in a table argument, which I found interesting. He also added business logic in javascript, which is client side and outside of the business logic tier. I hadn't thought about this before even though I've used javascript for validation for years, to along with server side validation.

My opinion is that you want the business logic in the application/middle tier as a rule of thumb, but don't discount cases where it makes sense to put it into the database.

One last point, there is another group where I'm working presently that is doing massive database work for research and the amount of data they are dealing with is immense. Still, for them they don't have any business logic in the database itself, but keep it in the application/middle tier. For their design, the application/middle tier was the correct place for it, so I wouldn't use the size of tables as the only design consideration.