Why use Select Top 100 Percent?

Question

I understand that prior to SQL Server 2005, you could \"trick\" SQL Server to allow use of an order by in a view definition, by also include TOP 100 PERCENT

Answer 1

It was used for "intermediate materialization (Google search)"

Good article: Adam Machanic: Exploring the secrets of intermediate materialization

He even raised an MS Connect so it can be done in a cleaner fashion

My view is "not inherently bad", but don't use it unless 100% sure. The problem is, it works only at the time you do it and probably not later (patch level, schema, index, row counts etc)...

Worked example

This may fail because you don't know in which order things are evaluated

SELECT foo From MyTable WHERE ISNUMERIC (foo) = 1 AND CAST(foo AS int) > 100

And this may also fail because

SELECT foo
FROM
    (SELECT foo From MyTable WHERE ISNUMERIC (foo) = 1) bar
WHERE
    CAST(foo AS int) > 100

However, this did not in SQL Server 2000. The inner query is evaluated and spooled:

SELECT foo
FROM
    (SELECT TOP 100 PERCENT foo From MyTable WHERE ISNUMERIC (foo) = 1 ORDER BY foo) bar
WHERE
    CAST(foo AS int) > 100

Note, this still works in SQL Server 2005

SELECT TOP 2000000000 ... ORDER BY...