DataContractSerializer doesn't call my constructor?

Question

I just realized something crazy, which I assumed to be completely impossible : when deserializing an object, the DataContractSerializer doesn\'t call the constructor

Answer 1

There are some scenario's that wouldn’t be possible without this behavior. Think of the following:

1) You have an object that has one constructor that sets the new instance to an "initialized" state. Then some methods are called on that instance, that bring it in a "processed" state. You don’t want to create new objects having the "processed" state, but you still want de serialize / deserialize the instance.

2) You created a class with a private constructor and some static properties to control a small set of allowed constructor parameters. Now you can still serialize / deserialize them.

XmlSerializer has the behavior you expected. I have had a some problems with the XmlSerializer because it DOES need a default constructor. Related to that, sometimes it makes sense to have private property setters. But the XmlSerializer also needs public getter and setter on properties in order to serialize / deserialize.

I think of the DataContractSerializer / BinaryFormatter behavior like suspending the state of an instance during serialization and resuming during deserialization. In other words, the instances are not “constructed” but “restored” to an earlier state.

As you already mentioned, the [OnDeserializing] attribute makes it possible to keep non serialized data in sync.