Can compiler optimization introduce bugs?

Question

Today I had a discussion with a friend of mine and we debated for a couple of hours about \"compiler optimization\".

I defended the point that sometimes

Answer 1

I certainly agree that it's silly to say the because compilers are written by "smart people" that they are therefore infallible. Smart people designed the Hindenberg and the Tacoma Narrows Bridge, too. Even if it's true that compiler-writers are among the smartest programmers out there, it's also true that compilers are among the most complex programs out there. Of course they have bugs.

On the other hand, experience tells us that the reliability of commercial compilers is very high. I've had many many times that someone told me that the reason why is program doesn't work MUST be because of a bug in the compiler because he has checked it very carefully and he is sure that it is 100% correct ... and then we find that in fact the program has an error and not the compiler. I'm trying to think of times that I've personally run across something that I was truly sure was an error in the compiler, and I can only recall one example.

So in general: Trust your compiler. But are they ever wrong? Sure.