Structure of Arrays vs Array of Structures in CUDA

Question

From some comments that I have read in here, for some reason it is preferable to have Structure of Arrays (SoA) over Array of Structures

Answer 1

I just want to provide a simple example showing how a Struct of Arrays (SoA) performs better than an Array of Structs (AoS).

In the example, I'm considering three different versions of the same code:

1. SoA (v1)
2. Straight arrays (v2)
3. AoS (v3)

In particular, version 2 considers the use of straight arrays. The timings of versions 2 and 3 are the same for this example and result to be better than version 1. I suspect that, in general, straight arrays could be preferable, although at the expense of readability, since, for example, loading from uniform cache could be enabled through const __restrict__ for this case.

#include "cuda_runtime.h"
#include "device_launch_parameters.h"

#include 

#include 

#include "Utilities.cuh"
#include "TimingGPU.cuh"

#define BLOCKSIZE   1024

/******************************************/
/* CELL STRUCT LEADING TO ARRAY OF STRUCT */
/******************************************/
struct cellAoS {

    unsigned int    x1;
    unsigned int    x2;
    unsigned int    code;
    bool            done;

};

/*******************************************/
/* CELL STRUCT LEADING TO STRUCT OF ARRAYS */
/*******************************************/
struct cellSoA {

    unsigned int    *x1;
    unsigned int    *x2;
    unsigned int    *code;
    bool            *done;

};


/*******************************************/
/* KERNEL MANIPULATING THE ARRAY OF STRUCT */
/*******************************************/
__global__ void AoSvsSoA_v1(cellAoS *d_cells, const int N) {

    const int tid = threadIdx.x + blockIdx.x * blockDim.x;

    if (tid < N) {
        cellAoS tempCell = d_cells[tid];

        tempCell.x1 = tempCell.x1 + 10;
        tempCell.x2 = tempCell.x2 + 10;

        d_cells[tid] = tempCell;
    }

}

/******************************/
/* KERNEL MANIPULATING ARRAYS */
/******************************/
__global__ void AoSvsSoA_v2(unsigned int * __restrict__ d_x1, unsigned int * __restrict__ d_x2, const int N) {

    const int tid = threadIdx.x + blockIdx.x * blockDim.x;

    if (tid < N) {

        d_x1[tid] = d_x1[tid] + 10;
        d_x2[tid] = d_x2[tid] + 10;

    }

}

/********************************************/
/* KERNEL MANIPULATING THE STRUCT OF ARRAYS */
/********************************************/
__global__ void AoSvsSoA_v3(cellSoA cell, const int N) {

    const int tid = threadIdx.x + blockIdx.x * blockDim.x;

    if (tid < N) {

        cell.x1[tid] = cell.x1[tid] + 10;
        cell.x2[tid] = cell.x2[tid] + 10;

    }

}

/********/
/* MAIN */
/********/
int main() {

    const int N = 2048 * 2048 * 4;

    TimingGPU timerGPU;

    thrust::host_vector    h_cells(N);
    thrust::device_vector  d_cells(N);

    thrust::host_vector   h_x1(N);
    thrust::host_vector   h_x2(N);

    thrust::device_vector d_x1(N);
    thrust::device_vector d_x2(N);

    for (int k = 0; k < N; k++) {

        h_cells[k].x1 = k + 1;
        h_cells[k].x2 = k + 2;
        h_cells[k].code = k + 3;
        h_cells[k].done = true;

        h_x1[k] = k + 1;
        h_x2[k] = k + 2;

    }

    d_cells = h_cells;

    d_x1 = h_x1;
    d_x2 = h_x2;

    cellSoA cell;
    cell.x1 = thrust::raw_pointer_cast(d_x1.data());
    cell.x2 = thrust::raw_pointer_cast(d_x2.data());
    cell.code = NULL;
    cell.done = NULL;

    timerGPU.StartCounter();
    AoSvsSoA_v1 << > >(thrust::raw_pointer_cast(d_cells.data()), N);
    gpuErrchk(cudaPeekAtLastError());
    gpuErrchk(cudaDeviceSynchronize());
    printf("Timing AoSvsSoA_v1 = %f\n", timerGPU.GetCounter());

    //timerGPU.StartCounter();
    //AoSvsSoA_v2 << > >(thrust::raw_pointer_cast(d_x1.data()), thrust::raw_pointer_cast(d_x2.data()), N);
    //gpuErrchk(cudaPeekAtLastError());
    //gpuErrchk(cudaDeviceSynchronize());
    //printf("Timing AoSvsSoA_v2 = %f\n", timerGPU.GetCounter());

    timerGPU.StartCounter();
    AoSvsSoA_v3 << > >(cell, N);
    gpuErrchk(cudaPeekAtLastError());
    gpuErrchk(cudaDeviceSynchronize());
    printf("Timing AoSvsSoA_v3 = %f\n", timerGPU.GetCounter());

    h_cells = d_cells;

    h_x1 = d_x1;
    h_x2 = d_x2;

    // --- Check results
    for (int k = 0; k < N; k++) {
        if (h_x1[k] != k + 11) {
            printf("h_x1[%i] not equal to %i\n", h_x1[k], k + 11);
            break;
        }
        if (h_x2[k] != k + 12) {
            printf("h_x2[%i] not equal to %i\n", h_x2[k], k + 12);
            break;
        }
        if (h_cells[k].x1 != k + 11) {
            printf("h_cells[%i].x1 not equal to %i\n", h_cells[k].x1, k + 11);
            break;
        }
        if (h_cells[k].x2 != k + 12) {
            printf("h_cells[%i].x2 not equal to %i\n", h_cells[k].x2, k + 12);
            break;
        }
    }

}

The following are the timings (runs performed on a GTX960):

Array of struct        9.1ms (v1 kernel)
Struct of arrays       3.3ms (v3 kernel)
Straight arrays        3.2ms (v2 kernel)