Delphi with SQL Server: OLEDB vs. Native Client drivers

Question

I have been told that SQL Native Client is supposed to be faster than the OLEDB drivers. So I put together a utility to do a load-test between the two - and am getting

Answer 1

Short answer:
It doesn't matter.

Long answer:
The difference in performance between the 2 client libs is relatively negligible compared to the Server execution + Network data transfer, which is what you are mostly measuring, hence the inconclusive test data. There is a good chance that you use the same low level layer in both cases anyway with only a minor difference in indirection on top of it.

As a matter of fact, if your tests show no visible difference, it just proves that the slowness is not related with the choice of the client lib and optimization should be searched elsewhere.

For your present test, you should use the SQL Profiler to measure the queries execution time on the Server at the same time you run your test, you would see that they vary also quite a bit. Subtracting those numbers from the test end results would give you the timing for the bundle Client time + Network transfer.

Network performance is quite variable and has more impact on your test than you would think. Try having someone streaming video at the same time you run your test and you will see... (Have had that with my former company; tuning the SQL was not the answer in this case )