Is it possible to subclass a C struct in C++ and use pointers to the struct in C code?

Question

Is there a side effect in doing this:

C code:

struct foo {
      int k;
};

int ret_foo(const struct foo* f){ 
    return f.k; 
}

C++ c

Answer 1

“Never derive from concrete classes.” — Sutter

“Make non-leaf classes abstract.” — Meyers

It’s simply wrong to subclass non-interface classes. You should refactor your libraries.

Technically, you can do what you want, so long as you don’t invoke undefined behavior by, e. g., deleting a pointer to the derived class by a pointer to its base class subobject. You don’t even need extern "C" for the C++ code. Yes, it’s portable. But it’s poor design.