Problem inflating custom view for AlertDialog in DialogFragment

Question

I\'m trying to create a DialogFragment using a custom view in an AlertDialog. This view must be inflated from xml. In my DialogFragment

Answer 1

I'm surprised by these answers as none of them solve the problem.

A DialogFragment allows you to reuse the same UI for both a dialog and integrated in your app elsewhere as a fragment. Quite a useful feature. As per google's documentation, you can achieve this by overriding onCreateDialog and onCreateView. http://developer.android.com/reference/android/app/DialogFragment.html

There are three scenarios here:

1. Override onCreateDialog only - Works as a dialog but cannot be integrated elsewhere.
2. Override onCreateView only - Does not work as a dialog but can be integrated elsewhere.
3. Override both - Works as a dialog and can be integrated elsewhere.

Solution: The AlertDialog class is calling another class which calls requestFeature. To fix this.. Don't use the AlertDialog, instead use a plain Dialog or whatever super.onCreateDialog returns. This the solution that I have found works best.

Caveat: Other dialogs such as DatePickerDialog, ProgressDialog, TimePickerDialog all inherit from AlertDialog and will likely cause the same error.

Bottom Line: DialogFragment is good if you need to create very customized interface that needs to be used in several places. It doesn't appear to work to reuse existing android dialogs.