Swift - CLGeocoder reverseGeocodeLocation completionHandler closure

只愿长相守 提交于 2019-11-28 18:19:46
AaronDancer

I found the answer I needed in this thread: Set address string with reverseGeocodeLocation: and return from method

The issue lies with the fact that reverseGeocodeLocation is asynchronous, the method is returning a value before the completionBlock sets p in my example.


As requested, here's my current code.

func showAddViewController(placemark:CLPlacemark){
    self.performSegueWithIdentifier("add", sender: placemark) 
}

func getPlacemarkFromLocation(location: CLLocation){
    CLGeocoder().reverseGeocodeLocation(location, completionHandler:
        {(placemarks, error) in
            if error {println("reverse geodcode fail: \(error.localizedDescription)")}
            let pm = placemarks as [CLPlacemark]
            if pm.count > 0 { self.showAddPinViewController(placemarks[0] as CLPlacemark) }
    })
}

I didn't want to take the NSNotificationCenter route because that would add unnecessary overhead, rather inside the completionHandler closure I call upon another function and pass the CLPlacemark generated by getPlacemarkFromLocation as a parameter to keep things asynchronous since the function will be called after placemarks is set the function (should) receive the placemark needed and execute the code you want. Hope what I said makes sense.

With these lines of Swift, you can print out fully the location's address:

func getLocationAddress(location:CLLocation) {
    var geocoder = CLGeocoder()

    println("-> Finding user address...")

    geocoder.reverseGeocodeLocation(location, completionHandler: {(placemarks, error)->Void in
        var placemark:CLPlacemark!

        if error == nil && placemarks.count > 0 {
            placemark = placemarks[0] as CLPlacemark

            var addressString : String = ""
            if placemark.ISOcountryCode == "TW" /*Address Format in Chinese*/ {
                if placemark.country != nil {
                    addressString = placemark.country
                }
                if placemark.subAdministrativeArea != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.subAdministrativeArea + ", "
                }
                if placemark.postalCode != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.postalCode + " "
                }
                if placemark.locality != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.locality
                }
                if placemark.thoroughfare != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.thoroughfare
                }
                if placemark.subThoroughfare != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.subThoroughfare
                }
            } else {
                if placemark.subThoroughfare != nil {
                    addressString = placemark.subThoroughfare + " "
                }
                if placemark.thoroughfare != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.thoroughfare + ", "
                }
                if placemark.postalCode != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.postalCode + " "
                }
                if placemark.locality != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.locality + ", "
                }
                if placemark.administrativeArea != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.administrativeArea + " "
                }
                if placemark.country != nil {
                    addressString = addressString + placemark.country
                }
            }

            println(addressString)
        }
    })
}

Cheers!

Here is closure that worked for me -- it took awhile to get it to work. I think your problem is related to not initializing p with the correct initializer. I tried a few variations until I got this to work: self.placemark = CLPlacemark(placemark: stuff[0] as CLPlacemark)

geocoder.reverseGeocodeLocation(newLocation, completionHandler: {(stuff, error)->Void in

        if error {
            println("reverse geodcode fail: \(error.localizedDescription)")
            return
        }

        if stuff.count > 0 {
            self.placemark = CLPlacemark(placemark: stuff[0] as CLPlacemark)

            self.addressLabel.text = String(format:"%@ %@\n%@ %@ %@\n%@",
                self.placemark.subThoroughfare ? self.placemark.subThoroughfare : "" ,
                self.placemark.thoroughfare ? self.placemark.thoroughfare : "",
                self.placemark.locality ? self.placemark.locality : "",
                self.placemark.postalCode ? self.placemark.postalCode : "",
                self.placemark.administrativeArea ? self.placemark.administrativeArea : "",
                self.placemark.country ? self.placemark.country : "")
        }
        else {
            println("No Placemarks!")
            return
        }

        })

EDIT:

moved better answer to its own answer.

EDIT: This doesn't work. The value is nil outside the closure -- see comments below

Your p is nil because the closure is capturing it before it is initialized to a reference. To get the behavior you want you need to make p a non-optional value such as var p : CLPlacemark!.

Below is code I used to test my conjecture:

 func locationManager(manager: CLLocationManager!, didUpdateToLocation newLocation: CLLocation!, fromLocation oldLocation: CLLocation!) {
    var g = CLGeocoder()
    var p:CLPlacemark?
    let mynil = "empty"
    g.reverseGeocodeLocation(newLocation, completionHandler: {
        (placemarks, error) in
        let pm = placemarks as? CLPlacemark[]
        if (pm && pm?.count > 0){
           // p = CLPlacemark()
            p = CLPlacemark(placemark: pm?[0] as CLPlacemark)

            println("Inside what is in p: \(p?.country ? p?.country : mynil)")

        }

        })

    println("Outside what is in p: \(p?.country ? p?.country : mynil)")

}

Here is console log:

Pushit <- button pressed to start location capturing
Outside what is in p: empty
Inside what is in p: United States
Outside what is in p: empty
Inside what is in p: United States
Outside what is in p: empty...

Bit late to this party, but it looks like you need(ed) to do some ground-up reading about async stuff. Saying that, you've probably learnt it by now.

The basic problem with your code is that p (your placemark) is being set after the function returns, so it's just lost - you can't use a function to return a value with async. With a completion closure, your code is passed the placemark when it arrives (asynchronously) & the closure is invoked - note the function is now returning nothing.

func getPlacemarkFromLocation(_ location: CLLocation, completion: ((CLPlacemark?) -> ())) {

    CLGeocoder().reverseGeocodeLocation(location, completionHandler: { (placemarks, error) in
        // use optional chaining to safely return a value or nil
        // also using .first rather than checking the count & getting placemarks[0] -
        // if the count is zero, will just give you nil
        // probably a good idea to check for errors too
        completion(placemarks?.first)
    })
}

Use -

getPlacemarkFromLocation(myLocation, completion: { (placemark) in
    // do something with the placemark here
})

I've not actually put this into Xcode, but it looks right...

Ryan Dines

Your stuff doesn't work for a number of reasons. Here's the part that I fixed without actually looking at the functionality:

class func getPlacemarkFromLocation(location:CLLocation)->CLPlacemark?{
    var g = CLGeocoder()
    var p:CLPlacemark?
    g.reverseGeocodeLocation(location, completionHandler: {
        (placemarks, error) in
        let pm = placemarks!
        if (pm.count > 0){
            p = placemarks![0]
        }
    })
    return p
}
易学教程内所有资源均来自网络或用户发布的内容,如有违反法律规定的内容欢迎反馈
该文章没有解决你所遇到的问题?点击提问,说说你的问题,让更多的人一起探讨吧!