Is there any way to keep a person authenticated with firebase across subdomains

问题

I use firebase for authentication on my website and I want to keep the users auth session active across subdomains.

Unfortunately, firebase uses Local Storage to store the user's session. Which unfortunately is independent to each subdomain.

I already know that you can generate a JWT token using firebase from the server side, but then it doesn't allow the user to log out of the site because the user would still end up logged in other subdomains.

回答1:

this is correct. Firebase only supports single host origin sessions. Firebase Auth is looking into supporting cookies. For now there is no easy solution for this. Feel free to request this feature at the Firebase forum: https://groups.google.com/forum/#!forum/firebase-talk

For now, if you really need this, here is one relatively easy option: Create an endpoint that takes a Firebase ID token and basically returns a custom token for its underlying user (you would need to use the Admin SDK to do this, you verify then ID token, get the user UID and then mint a custom token). The subdomain where the user signed in would pass the ID token to the other subdomain where the user is still not authenticated (you can use iframe cross origin postMessage to pass it, or just save that ID token in a *.domain.com policy). The custom token can then be used to signInWithCustomToken with the custom token, effectively signing in the same user on this page.

This is risky though as the endpoint could expose a vulnerability (it transforms a short lived token to an indefinite one). If the ID token is leaked, an attacker can basically sign-in as the user exploiting this endpoint.

回答2:

After having spent much longer then I intended to getting single-sign-in working across subdomains, I wrote up a blog post detailing how to accomplish this.

As a high level overview (which ignores the important security details):

1. We have three applications at different domains.

   • accounts.domain.com
   • app1.domain.com
   • app2.domain.com

2. We have three Firebase Functions

   • ...cloudfunctions.net/users-signin
   • ...cloudfunctions.net/users-checkAuthStatus
   • ...cloudfunctions.net/users-signout

In order to sign in:

1. Someone navigates to the accounts.domain.com app
2. They provide their authentication information
3. That authentication information is sent to our /users-signin cloud function which verifies the information and, if valid, sets a signed __session cookie which contains the user's UID and returns a success indication to the client.
4. On success, the client calls the /users-checkAuthStatus cloud function which looks for the signed __session cookie, extracts the user UID, and uses the UID and the firebase-admin SDK to mint a custom auth token which it returns to the client.
5. When the client receives this custom auth token, it uses it to sign in using the firebase javascript SDK.
6. When someone navigates to one of the other apps, say app1.domain.com, the app first checks to see if the person is already signed in using the firebase javascript SDK.
   1. If they are, awesome.
   2. If not, it calls the /users-checkAuthStatus cloud function which looks for the signed __session cookie and returns a custom auth token to the client if a valid __session cookie is found.
      • If a custom auth token is returned, the client uses it to sign the user in using the firebase sdk.
      • If a custom auth token is not returned, it means the user isn't authenticated. You can then optionally redirect them to the authentication app to sign in.

Again, this is a high level overview which ignores issues like cross-site-scripting attacks, actually signing out, etc. For more information, check out the blog post.

回答3:

The iframe doesn't work anymore for Safari because it doesn't let the iframe's origin page access its own indexeddb anymore. That means you cannot get the id token and onAuthStateChanged will always return null.

We've implemented another solution where we store a custom token into a secure cookie along with a redirect information, redirect the user to the other domain, use the cookie to sign in or sign out the user, delete the cookie and redirect him again to the location stored in the cookie.

1. Login
2. Get custom token
3. Set cookie with action "signIn" or "signOut", redirectUrl and token (if signIn)
4. Redirect to other page
5. Sign in or sign out
6. Delete cookie
7. Redirect to redirectUrl

That works for iOS and Desktop Safari again. But it only works if it's on the same domain so that both subdomains are going to have access to that cookie.

回答4:

I used NGINX to load diffrent web apps which want to share same firebase auth which works out of box in firebase if domain or sub domain is same.

server {
root /var/lib/jenkins/workspace/app/dist;
index index.html index.htm index.nginx-debian.html;
server_name app.com; # example

location /app1 {
        alias /var/lib/jenkins/workspace/app1/dist;
        try_files $uri $uri/ =404;
}

location /app2 {
        alias /var/lib/jenkins/workspace/app2;
        try_files $uri $uri/ =404;
} 

location /static {
        alias /var/lib/jenkins/workspace/build/static;
        try_files $uri $uri/ =404;
}

location ~ /\.ht {
    deny all;
}

listen 80;
listen [::]:80; 

}

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/45060642/is-there-any-way-to-keep-a-person-authenticated-with-firebase-across-subdomains