How is the value of a begin block determined?

问题

According to The Ruby Programming Language p.164.

If a begin statement doesn't propagate an exception, then the value of the statement is the value of the last expression evaluated in the begin, rescue or else clauses.

But I found this behavior consistent with the begin block together with else clause and ensure clause.

Here is the example code:

def fact (n)
  raise "bad argument" if n.to_i < 1
end

value = begin
  fact (1)
rescue RuntimeError => e
  p e.message
else
  p "I am in the else statement"
ensure
  p "I will be always executed"
  p "The END of begin block"
end

p value

The output is:

"I am in the else statement"
"I will be always executed"
"The END of begin block"
"I am in the else statement"
[Finished]

The value is evaluated to the else clause. This is inconsistent behavior as the ensure clause is the last statement executed.

Could someone explain what's happening within the begin block?

回答1:

I'd interpret the goal of the begin/rescue/else/end block as:

Execute the code in the begin section, and then the code in the else section.
If something goes wrong in the begin section, execute the rescue section instead of the else section.

So either the rescue section or the else section will be executed after trying the begin section; so it makes sense that one of them will be used as the whole block's value.

It's simply a side effect that the ensure section will always be executed.

val = begin
  p "first"; "first"
rescue => e
  p "fail"; "fail"
else
  p "else"; "else"
ensure
  p "ensure"; "ensure"
end

val # => "else"
# >> "first"
# >> "else"
# >> "ensure"

But:

val = begin
  p "first"; "first"
  raise
rescue => e
  p "fail"; "fail"
else
  p "else"; "else"
ensure
  p "ensure"; "ensure"
end

val # => "fail"
# >> "first"
# >> "fail"
# >> "ensure"

回答2:

I'm just guessing here, but as the purpose of a ensure block is to finalize any resources that may remain open (cleanup in other words), and so it makes sense that the logical value should be the result of the else statement. It makes sense to me that it is by design.

回答3:

In this case the begin block is just a way of defining a section for which you may want to do exception handling.

Remember that else in this case runs if no exceptions occur, and ensure will run regardless of exceptions or a lack thereof.

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/9687579/how-is-the-value-of-a-begin-block-determined

标签

ruby

expression

block