问题
I have a folder in NTFS that contains tens of thousands of files. I've deleted all files in that folder, save 1. I ran contig.exe to defragment that folder so now it's in 1 fragment only. However, the size of that folder is still 8MB in size. This implies that there's a lot of gap in the index. Why is that? If I delete that one file, the size of the index automatically goes to zero. My guess is because it gets collapsed into the MFT. Is there any way to get NTFS to truly defragment the index file by defragmenting it based on the content of the file? Any API that you're aware of? Contig.exe only defragment the physical file.
回答1:
I guess this is one way in which NTFS is just like almost every other FS - none of them seem to like shrinking directories.
So you should apply a high-tech method that involves using that advanced language, "BAT" :)
collapse.bat
REM Invoke as "collapse dirname"
ren dirname dirname.old
mkdir dirname
cd dirname.old
move * ../dirname/
cd ..
rmdir dirname.old
回答2:
There is slack in the index, but not a gap. I make the distinction to imply that there is technically wasted space, but it's not like NTFS has to parse the 8MB in order to enumerate/query/whatever the index. It knows where the root of its tree is, and it just happens to have a lot of extra allocation leftover. Probably too detailed a response, given how unhelpful it is.
Fragmentation is likely a separate issue altogether.
回答3:
Take a look at the accepted answer to this question: NTFS performance and large volumes of files and directories
The author provided some otherwise undocumented information about file index fragmentation, which he received from Microsoft Tech Support during an incident. The short version is, DEFRAG does not defragment the folder index, only the files in that folder. If you want to defragment the file index, you have to use SysInternals' CONTIG tool, which is now owned and distributed (free) by Microsoft. The answer gives a link to CONTIG.
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/291336/how-do-you-reduce-the-size-of-a-folders-index-file-in-ntfs