node.js: while loop callback not working as expected

问题

Knowing that while Node.js is working asynchronously, writing something like this:

function sleep() {
    var stop = new Date().getTime();
    while(new Date().getTime < stop + 15000) {
        ;
    }
}

sleep();
console.log("done");

...would call the sleep(), block the server for the duration of the while loop (15secs) and just THEN print "done" to the console. As far as I understand, this is because Node.js is giving JavaScript only access to the main thread, and therefore this kidn of thing would halt further execution.

So I understand the solution to this is to use callbacks:

function sleep(callback) {
    var stop = new Date().getTime();
    while(new Date().getTime() < stop + 15000) {
        ;
    }
    callback();
}

sleep(function() {
    console.log("done sleeping");
});

console.log("DONE");

So I thought this would print 'DONE' and after 15 secs. 'done sleeping', since the sleep() function gets called and is handed a pointer to a callback function. While this function is working (the while loop), the last line would be executed (print 'done'). After 15 seconds, when the sleep() function finishes, it calls the given callback function, which then prints 'done sleeping'.

Apparently I understood something wrong here, because both of the above ways block. Can anybody clarify please?

Thanks in advance, Slagjoeyoco

回答1:

Javascript and node.js are single threaded, which means a simple while blocks; no requests/events can be processed until the while block is done. Callbacks don't magically solve this problem, they just help pass custom code to a function. Instead, iterate using process.nextTick, which will give you esentially the same results but leaves space for requests and events to be processed as well, ie, it doesn't block:

function doSleep(callback) {
    var stop = new Date().getTime();

    process.nextTick(function() {
        if(new Date().getTime() < stop + 15000) {
            //Done, run callback
            if(typeof callback == "function") {
                callback();
            }
        } else {
            //Not done, keep looping
            process.nextTick(arguments.callee);
        }
    });
}

doSleep(function() {
    console.log("done sleeping");
    console.log("DONE");
});

回答2:

You are calling sleep right away, and the new sleep function blocks. It keeps iterating until the condition is met. You should use setTimeout() to avoid blocking:

setTimeout(function () {
    console.log('done sleeping');
}, 15000);

回答3:

Callbacks aren't the same thing as asynchronicity, they're just helpful when you want to get a... callback... from an asynchronous operation. In your case, the method still executes synchronously; Node doesn't just magically detect that there's a callback and long-running operation, and make it return ahead of time.

The real solution is to use setTimeout instead of a busy loop on another thread.

回答4:

As already mentioned, asynchronous execution should be achieved by setTimeout() rather than while, because while will freeze in one "execution frame".

Also it seems you have syntax error in your example.

This one works fine: http://jsfiddle.net/6TP76/

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/12868804/node-js-while-loop-callback-not-working-as-expected

标签

javascript

node.js

loops

callback

while-loop