How can CString be passed to format string %s?

问题

class MyString
{
public:
    MyString(const std::wstring& s2)
    {
        s = s2;
    }

    operator LPCWSTR() const
    {
        return s.c_str();
    }
private:
    std::wstring s;
};

int _tmain(int argc, _TCHAR* argv[])
{
    MyString s = L"MyString";
    CStringW cstring = L"CString";
    wprintf(L"%s\n", (LPCWSTR)cstring); // Okay. Becase it has an operator LPCWSTR()
    wprintf(L"%s\n", cstring); // Okay, fine. But how?        
    wprintf(L"%s\n", (LPCWSTR)s); // Okay. fine.
    wprintf(L"%s\n", s); // Doesn't work. Why? It prints gabage string like "?."
    return 0;
}

How can CString be passed to format string %s?

By the way, MSDN says(it's weird)

To use a CString object in a variable argument function
Explicitly cast the CString to an LPCTSTR string, as shown here:

CString kindOfFruit = "bananas";
int      howmany = 25;
printf( "You have %d %s\n", howmany, (LPCTSTR)kindOfFruit ); 

回答1:

CString is specifically designed such that it only contains a pointer that points to the string data in a buffer class. When passed by value to printf it will be treated as a pointer when seeing the "%s" in the format string.

It originally just happened to work with printf by chance, but this has later been kept as part of the class interface.

---

This post is based on MS documentation long since retired, so I cannot link to their promise that they will continue to make this work.

However, before adding more downvotes please also read this blog post from someone sharing my old knowledge:

Big Brother helps you

回答2:

    wprintf(L"%s\n", (LPCWSTR)cstring); // Okay. It's been cast to a const wchar_t*.
    wprintf(L"%s\n", cstring); // UNDEFINED BEHAVIOUR
    wprintf(L"%s\n", (LPCWSTR)s); // Okay, it's a const wchar_t*.
    wprintf(L"%s\n", s); // UNDEFINED BEHAVIOUR

The only thing you can pass to this function for %s is a const wchar_t*. Anything else is undefined behaviour. Passing the CString just happens to work.

There's a reason that iostream was developed in C++, and it's because these variable-argument functions are horrifically unsafe, and shoud never be used. Oh, and CString is pretty much a sin too for plenty of reasons, stick to std::wstring and cout/wcout wherever you can.

回答3:

CString has a pointer as the first member:

class CStringA
{
      char* m_pString;
};

Though it is not char* (even for ANSI CString), it is more or less the same thing. When you pass CString object to any of printf-family of functions (including your custom implementation, if any), you are passing CString object (which is on stack). The %s parsing causes it it read as if it was a pointer - which is a valid pointer in this case (the data at very first byte is m_pString).

回答4:

Generally speaking it's undefined behavior. According to this article Visual C++ just invokes the conversion from CString to a POD type to cover you - that is permissible implementation of undefined behavior.

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/6608942/how-can-cstring-be-passed-to-format-string-s