removeCallbacks not stopping runnable

Question

I am calling from a method:

myHandler.postDelayed(mMyRunnableHide, 6000);

which calls:

public Runnable mMyRunnableHide = new Runnable()
{

    public void run()
    {
        mTextDisplay.setText("");
        DisplayX();
    }
 };

if a button on screen is clicked I want to stop the runnable:

   Button next = (Button) findViewById(R.id.Breaction);
    next.setOnClickListener(new View.OnClickListener() {
        public void onClick(View view) {

            myHandler.removeCallbacks(mMyRunnableHide);

            mTextDisplay.setText("");
            DisplayX();
            }
        });   
    }

the removecallbacks is not stopping the runnable. What am I doing wrong? Am I using the correct method? I just want the runnable to "Not Run" when the user clicks the button.

Thanks for any help.

Answer 1

It appears to me that removeCallbacks(..) only stops pending messages (Runnables). If your runnable has already started, then there's no stopping it (at least not this way).

Alternatively, you can extend the Runnable class and give it some kind of kill switch like this:

public class MyRunnable implements Runnable
{
   private boolean killMe = false;

   private void run()
   {
      if(killMe)
         return;

      /* do your work */
   }

   private void killRunnable()
   {
      killMe = true;
   }
}

This will only prevent it from starting, but you could occasionally check killMe and bail out. If you are looping the runnable (like some kind of background thread) you can say:

while(!killMe) {
   /* do work */
}

Hope this helps

EDIT I just wanted to post an update on this. Since this original post, Google has come up with a great class called AsyncTask that handles all of this stuff for you. Anyone reading this really should look into it because it is the correct way of doing things.

You can read about it here

Answer 2

Handler.removeCallback is synchronous and will work nicely provided:

1. You call postDelayed always in the main thread.
2. You call removeCallback always in the main thread
3. You don't call postDelayed again after having removed callbacks.

So in your case removeCallbacks is called from a button handler, which runs in the main thread. But you didn't show in your code the point from where you call postDelayed. If you call it from a background thread thats where your problem is.

If you are sure you don't call any of these methods from background threads, and the order of the calls is correct, then you might be leaving uncancelled tasks unadvertedly alive due to activity recreation on config changes (screen rotation, etc). Always make sure to call removeCallbacks again in the onDestroy method to prevent this kind of problems.

Answer 3

Here is another way to accomplish what mtmurdock is describing. This class will allow editing of instance variables in any class that your Runnable is defined as an anonymous inner class.

package support;

/**
* Runnable that can be stopped from executing
*/
public abstract class KillableRunnable implements Runnable{

private boolean isKilled=false;

/**
 * Instead of Overriding run(), override this method to perform a Runnable operation. 
 * This will allow editing instance variables in the class that this Runnable is defined
 */
public abstract void doWork();

//The handler that posts this Runnable will call this method. 
//By default, check if it has been killed. doWork() will now be the method 
//override to implement this Runnable
@Override
final public void run(){
    if(!isKilled){
        doWork();
    }
}

final public void kill(){
    isKilled=true;
}
}

Answer 4

I don't think that removeCallbacks(..) only stops pending messages (Runnables) ，I think removeCallbacks(..) not working have other cause,but i don‘t know. because postDelayed(..) and removeCallbacks(..) is in the same thread